Jedidiah Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Architecture

Bloomsbury Estates Marketing Video Bonanza

The conversation about Bloomsbury Estates seems to never end. Some love its “historical references”, while others reject its relevance to 21st century design. Regardless of the opposing opinions, construction continues, move-in is slated for September, and the powers-that-be for the hilltop mansion have released new marketing videos that are sure to entertain at least a few.

Three videos that will serve as tools to entice future buyers surfaced recently on the internet. One of the videos is listed as a TV spot and the other two look to be web-based marketing aids. The TV spot is relatively harmless. It creates an essential, although bland, portrayal of the soon to be finished residential complex, actually showing both towers (only one of which is currently under construction). It is short and concise, lasting a tame 34 seconds.

Contrary to the minimal tv spot, the first of the two web based ads, entitled “Life Without Compromise” is almost 7 minutes long.  It repeats a handful of typical sales phrases and becomes quite hypnotic after the first few minutes. It paints a picture of Bloomsbury Estates via audio and visuals that echo a video advert inside of a corporate skyscraper elevator (or dentist’s office) circa 1992. I think I nodded off a couple times while watching. Shouldn’t a marketing ad grab my attention.  Oh, yeah (no pun intended) there’s a third video. Maybe that’s the one they are saving all the pizazz for.

As the third video starts, a view of the Raleigh skyline pans across the screen and a familiar and slightly campy song starts. “Oh Yeah! Chiga Chiga!” Text slowly fades onto the screen. “Life on the Edge of Urban” it states. A couple of images of Boylan Heights pan across, then an espresso machine, some folks having martinis, more Boylan Heights, a stock photo of workers clearly not walking down a Raleigh street, and then a couple of nondescript videos of Raleigh bars. The phrases “Live Events”, “Urban Energy”, “Tree-lined streets” and “The City’s Heartbeat” all make an appearance with these images. Then then video abruptly comes to an end.

Bloomsbury Estates - Life on the Edge of Urban

The imagery and text used in all three videos is recycled, with the only difference in the three videos being the audio. From jazz to soft electro, and finally Yello? Yello was an electro-syth band (and quite good one at that) in the 80’s that had few hits, but the few they had are very recognizable. Many of us remember Yello’s song “Oh Yeah” from the end credits of Ferris Bueller’s Day Off. There’s something nice and fitting about the use of “Oh Yeah” at the end of this film, which played on Friday at the NC Art Museum. There’s a certain abstract experimental nature about this song that requires a bit of care, even satirical care, when placing it in the context of video. Just look at Yello’s original video for the song and you’ll see an experimentation that can only be replicated by a humorous or stylish replication of this attitude. The Bloomsbury Estates Ad misses this opportunity. Watching Yello’s video, you get it. Watching Bloomsbury Estates’ attempt, you question it.

We’ve seen various attempts at marketing the many new condos that are going up in and around downtown, but this one takes the cake. The video has little style but attempts to throw in a nostalgic soundtrack and photos to attract buyers. With recycled and poorly edited visuals, this marketing campaign is slightly less annoying than Hue’s Crayola Sponsored Video or West at North’s Pardon Me for Living Ads. There are great marketing campaigns and videos out there with a good amount of style. Raleigh’s condo marketing teams could learn a bit from the marketing of the 40 Bond condos, Sigeru Ban’s The Shutter Houses in New York City, OMA’s CCTV complex in China, or the fabulous process based video (keep watching) for the Museum Plaza building in Louisville.

Bloomsbury claims that the estates are “Life on the Edge of Urban, in the Midst of Neighborhood Bliss” with “Killer views, timeless architecture and quality construction. Historic charm with modern convenience.” If so, create a bit of marketing that expresses these issues either logically or stylistically. These ads, especially the latter does neither. It shows a nonchalant attitude of copying and pasting various “needed imagery and audio” into a formula that could attract buyers. The new downtown needs more than this. We need more than martinis (the olive dropped in the glass gets me every time). We need more than the phrases “looking down onto historic bungalows” and “European gardens” to entice new residents. We need more than the schizophrenic metro-retro marketing. We need integration. We need design. We need style...or at least a video artist for your marketing team, Downtown Raleigh already has a handful of those.

Welcome to New Raleigh. We welcome your participation in the ongoing discussion. If you are new we invite you to register with our site. With registration you can upload a picture, message other users, and comment more easily. If you want to keep up with the site, subscribe to our RSS feed or get emailed every time we post.

  • Ashton07/15 10:36 AM

    The longer video I believe runs in the sales center, and knowing that they have 2 that run in there I bet the other is one too.

  • Jason!07/15 10:38 AM

    Are you sure these videos aren’t supposed to go in the next entry?  They’re freaking me out, man.

  • my2cents07/15 11:21 AM

    Although it is exciting to see downtown Raleigh being revitalized, the developers are not building for the people that downtown Raleigh needs to create the urban atmosphere portrayed in this video. Espresso-drinking, young 20- and 30-something professionals who enjoy things like the “downtown pulse”, “urban energy”, and “nightlife” can’t afford most of the housing being built downtown right now. No, the developers are building for richer, older folks who weekend at their home on the coast and need a $300k-$500k condo to maintain their interests in town during the week. These aren’t the folks who are going to be adding to the downtown pulse. When is downtown going to get affordable “urban” housing for young singles, couples, and families?

  • GB07/15 12:01 PM

    “We need more than martinis (the olive dropped in the glass gets me every time).”

    HA! That’s pretty funny!

    But in all seriousness, I agree with what you’re trying to say here.

  • Robert E Leebowitz07/15 12:46 PM

    Oh Yeah!!!

    I think this IS marketing to older folks.  Those who imagine themselves being like espresso drinking 20 and 30-somethings, full of Urban Energy.  The reality would be a sofa full of 25-year olds playing Guitar Hero with a bong at their feet and fixed gear bikes crowding the room.  Reality doesn’t sell condos.  Yello does!

  • David07/15 01:23 PM

    REL speaks the Truth better than our bitter “The Truth” does.. Although Im not sure the Fixie crowd overlaps with the XBox crowd as much as you would expect.

  • DPK07/15 02:24 PM

    Wow, that video was annoying, but I digress.

    Developers need to realize that they have a huge market in Raleigh of young people that really do want to live in an urban environment.  However very little of us can actually afford to buy a condo to do that.  The only hope right now is really 712 Tucker that will have rentals.

    Yes I realize that there are other rental properties downtown, but they are far and few between.

  • emily07/15 03:43 PM

    REL- you crack me up. 

    Developers don’t care about the market of young people.  Why would they?
    We’re pretty broke.

  • B07/15 10:19 PM

    Looks like a good ad for Raleigh but what was it for. I can’t remember. But I do have a craving for “Duck and The Dumpling”.

    ps- This is what happens when people don’t want to spend money and hire professionals. They probably spent weeks working on this project, and it doesn’t even sell their product. Now they wasted all that time to only create an ad for downtown Raleigh.

  • JT07/16 07:26 AM

    New BE residents should enjoy the enhanced views of the Central Prison after the DOC recently removed the only buffer between their Urban Oasis and BE/Boylan Heights.  Someone has some explaining to do…

  • Jamison Heart07/16 09:19 AM

    Great post and discussion.  Here’s a video for Blount Street Commons:

    http://www.myriadmedia.net/844_BSC/V1.html

    What do ya’ll think of that one?

  • B07/16 09:45 AM

    JH, Looks pretty good. I like the us of image cut-outs to give depth and movement. I been wanting to try the technic on a future project. I know when working with builders they are limited on renderings, etc. I did notice that there is a fast spot later in the clip, and the copy gets lost in the visuals in some parts, and a music trac wouldn’t hurt.

    http://www.lascalauptown.com/
    check this site out

  • Jamison Heart07/16 10:14 AM

    Good points, B.  I appreciate your perspective.  The company I work for, Myriad Media, is a DTR film and video company that produced this anima for the BSC agency at the time (SteeleMcKinney).

    Per your thoughts on music, if you listen there are lots of interesting and subtle sound accents...more of a foley effect.  A good music track certainly has its place and was considered, but this approach was selected due to the need to not overwhelm the sales center with the same track being played over and over again and other reasons.

    I think this piece plays only in the BSC sales center on high def and looks great.

    The original post is right on:  We need design. We need style.  There are lots of good agencies in DTR capable of doing good work, but the builder market is tough.  In my experience, it’s not an area that spends lots of money on atypical marketing approaches.  They know print, display, etc. and aren’t inclined to take “risks” with the unconventional.  That also impacts just how far you can push the client into approaches that are truly optimized for the medium..versus taking renderings and photos and mashing them up into a video.

    Again, good points, B.

  • B07/16 10:22 AM

    jh-I forgot to post one more thing. The flash video could use the buffering component. this will let people know that the video hasn’t just stopped. It did that a couple of times on my computer. But, then again I don’t have alot of bandwidth.

  • RabornMcNamara07/16 01:26 PM

    Walked by the building today (it had been awhile).  Like the video, its pretending to be something its not and it really shows.  Flattened facade, no quoining at the corners, ill-proportioned turret.

    Even a wolf must show his eyes in the sheep suit.

    I have to say the video is spot on with the what they’re offering.

  • ChiefJoJo07/16 11:19 PM

    I actually can appreciate the design (minus the lack of street focus), but the video is ridiculous.  Awful.  Ironic that the inspiration of the design (modern Victorian?) was the historic neighborhood that is rests on/near… the first county courthouse stood there and it’s just 100 yards from one of the oldest homes in Wake County, the Joel Lane House.  No inclusion of those themes?

  • Betsy07/18 07:43 AM

    Oh do come on now.  The whole point of the video is that there will always be a home in Raleigh for people with more money than taste.

  • Al07/24 03:14 PM

    Looks almost like the stuff that got dee-stroyed back when “they” were busy moving everyone out for the failed suburban hustle, only the thing is styrofoam—all the substance of a Hollywood backlot, and oh boy that western view! There might be a good side job for artist, painting views the windows, to conceal the new five story monsters on the Central property

  • Arthur07/26 08:24 AM

    Now with the addition of the new prison hospital the hood is up in arms and all over themselves about the expanding prison on the West and the ghetto hoods on the East.

    I think its funny when people from other areas move there then slowly realize what’s around them!

  • lone gunman08/13 04:27 PM

    The fun thing about New Raleigh blogs are that they are set in motion by some wit and intellectual process, but are commented on by some who obstinately stand on soapboxes made of nothing more than narrow opinion and sublime folly.

    As far as any sales video; they are produced solely to entice and attract attention… it seems proven by this blog that this requirement is being met. As the old Hollywood phrase goes ‘it doesn’t matter what they say as long as they are talking about you.’

    As in the past uneducated discussion about the architecture and design of the building, the bloggers who do nothing more than critique the work of others would do well to remember that their taste or opinion was not, nor should it have been, at play in processes of design which is in turn creating this built form.

    I believe that personal taste shared is the first refuge of the non-creative.

    We must be free to type or speak our opinions on all subject to be sure, but all creative works, be they from the pen, wheel or hammer must be viewed with the freedom of the designer in mind or we ourselves will collectively build a mental prison to which we will all be sentenced. As Dali once penned on a similar subject regarding critiques of others work: “it is good taste, and good taste alone, that possesses the power to sterilize and is always the first handicap to any creative functioning.”

    Let us all stay free from taste and judgment.

  • JZ08/13 05:04 PM

    Wow.  I have to say that your comments have given me pause.  Despite the fact that Dali was a trickster and could never be taken at face value. 

    Also, I would like to offer that critique of any design is not NECESSARILY playing to preconceived formulas of acceptable solutions, high or low, left or right.  Any form of design --whether it be a building or a street curb or a toothbrush-- evokes a response in the user.  By your measure, silence on matters of our built environment is more important than raising your voice in protest of something intolerable.  By your measure, the Raleigh Prison expansion should be tolerated despite design decisions to negatively impact the Boylan Heights neighborhood by tearing down the landscape buffer.  By your measure, low-quality materials like the synthetic stucco on the new Marriott downtown should be an acceptable material choice on Raleigh’s main street. I think I have to disagree, not because of taste, but for the same reason I do not eat rotting vegetables or undercooked meat.

    That being said, I appreciate your point that a certain measure of criticism is necessary and I have to admit leaning to some vocal extremes at times.  Your comments are taken seriously, and it gives me reason to think a bit more before start spewing filth. 

    It has always been my intent to look beyond the appearance of things and comment on how the particular building behaves in the larger context of our city. 

    Action, indeed, speaks louder than words.  If we all got out from behind these damn screens we’d be better authorities on what is good for our town.

  • Enigma08/13 06:36 PM

    Hey LG; this is AMERICA my friend.  Last time I checked we still have the right to openly express our thoughts and opinions, whether for or against, anything.  If doing so is the act of judgment in some minds, so be it.  Ever heard of book or movie critics? 

    GOD BLESS AMERICA!




Remember my information for next time I comment

Send me an email of follow-up comments?