February
29
2008
Mark

Clarence E. Lightner Public Safety Center Pre-Design


Click Image for Slideshow

The Clarence E. Lightner Public Safety Center will combine the City Police and Fire Departments, Emergency Communications and Operations, Traffic Control, Information Technology and Data, Sheriff Dispatch, Building Maintenance and Credit Union Offices all into one building.  Kling Stubbins presented conceptual designs for the building before the City Council last week; they put forth their design concept that local government should not be expressed as a monolith, but that the programmatic elements gathered by this project should be reflected through the form of the building, specifically, as “parts and pieces.”

Efforts thus far give strong attention towards Nash Square and the site as a pedestrian corridor.   The transparent lobby of the building acts as a “front porch,” and a buffer from the street.  In addition to consolidating many city offices, the building will contain an auditorium and cafe.  The 300,000 square foot facility will attempt a LEED Gold rating.  Cherry Huffman will serve as the architect of record.

Last year’s RFQ listed the bill at $100 Million.  The projected cost today is $184 million.  Add a $40+ million contingency for inflation and the final cost is estimated to round off near $225 million at completion.  This project is in the infantile stages of design, and this affords the opportunity for the public to give input on the design, and perhaps influence the outcome.

Ultimately, this is the public’s building.  And we are paying for it. 

Related Posts:

Arts Commission to Review Public Art Funding
Bike Ride to Show Council Support for Hillsborough Bike Lanes
Candidates file for City Council & School Board Seats
City Council Approves Solar Plant

Tagged: City Council, Clarence E. Lightner Public Safety Center, Firefighters, Police

Read More: Architecture , Other posts by Mark.

  • Michael
    02/29 02:03 PM

    Looks like they’ve got a good start.  Maybe the County will take some cues from this for their building.  Any word on the level of LEED certification they think they’ll get?

  • Mark
    02/29 02:27 PM

    I think the Wake County Justice Center is going for basic LEED certification.  The Lightner Center will try for Gold, which is two rungs up from basic.

  • Cydney
    02/29 02:56 PM

    I’d also like to point out that this facility is smaller than the Justice Center and has a larger budget and a larger contingency.  I’d guess, but don’t know, that the fees associated with LEED Gold would be higher than that required for basic?  This building design seems, at first glance, to reflect not only lessons learned from the Convention Center project but also the City’s efforts toward sustainability and good public buildings.  Unlike the Justice Center plan, this suggests an open, cooperative and convenient government.

  • brian_M
    02/29 10:35 PM

    It really dwarfs the 5 story current City Hall next door. Considering how crappy the space (Raleigh’s previous City Hall) the police department is currently shoe-horned in, this is wonderful for them. I am, however, a bit frightened by the price tag. Mainly because right-wing crazies are getting stirred up by it…this is the kind of thing that wins them elections, and Raleigh is a city that needs to keep on the progressive path it’s been on for the past several years.

  • RaleighRob
    03/01 02:03 AM

    Good points, Brian.  I hope they strongly push a tighter budget on it to keep the criticism to a minimum. 
    But overall, I like to see a taller, larger building to centralize city services.  After spending a week in Asheville and seeing their majestic City Hall take prominence on the skyline, it makes me wish for similar for Raleigh. Some type of government structure other than the jail to be seen from a distance would be nice!  tongue laugh

  • Magnus
    07/01 05:07 PM

    Nothing like putting all of your eggs in one basket.

  • Linda
    08/21 09:16 PM

    It is a fine idea to name locations for former leaders but very ironic that the Public Safety building is being named for someone that did nothing for PS.
    There were allegations of wrong doing by the mayor’s wife. Check into old files and you will locate the information on shoplifting.
    The City needs to reconsider the naming of the PS building.  Being politically correct has been highly overrated.
    There are many other deserving people who the building could be named for.

  • Troy
    10/13 09:33 AM

    This is a project that has been known of for a while, but more information is coming out. The Clarence Lightner Public Safety Center will be the future home of administrative personnel for Raleigh’s Fire and Police departments. Additionally the building may house some other city offices. Preliminary plans call for a 15 story building with 260,000 sq ft of office space. The building will be built next to the Avery C. Upchurch government complex on Hargett Street (Site currently occupied by a police station). More information as it becomes available.

    Thoughts about the project so far

    I’m a little disappointed with the size. In my opinion Raleigh really needs to take this opportunity to build a true city hall that holds all city offices. While its great that Raleigh stepped in to occupy One Exchange Plaza, its time to consolidate all the city offices. Also at the rate that Raleigh is growing city government is only going to expand. This building should probably be bumped up about 5-10 stories of office space AND incorporate at least a few levels of parking.

    Overall this would free up another parcel adjacent to Nash Square. Also if Raleigh what’s an “iconic” building a 25 story building in this location would REALLY stand out on the skyline.

  • revolu
    10/13 10:38 AM

    my problem with so many public buildings is the lack of scale at the street.  that canopy image is a bit disturbing, as well as the price tag as many have mentioned already.  it looks like they “might” do some interesting things with the facade/skin though.  it’s just hard to tell from those pics. 

    i hope to hear more detail on this project though since it is such a steep thing for the taxpayers, especially at right now.  hope they bring some activity to that area.

Your Comment

We welcome on-topic corrections, criticism, ideas and insight: read our policy.





If you're not yet registered with New Raleigh, join now so you can share your opinions and insight.

It's fast free and your information will remain private.

Register