JZ Friday, February 15, 2008

Architecture

Everything Comes At A Price - A Living Eulogy For The Garland Jones Office Building

image
In Downtown Raleigh at the corner of Salisbury and Martin Streets resides the remarkable structure formerly known as the First Federal Bank Building.  Renamed the Garland Jones Office Building, it houses Wake County’s Register of Deeds. The American Institute of Architects has identified it as one of the 88 most important 20th Century structures in Raleigh.  The building has also been identified as a contributing structure in a study to designate the Fayetteville Street District as a Federal Historic District.  Most remarkable is the fact that it is the last remaining example of High Modern Architecture in the downtown core. A myriad of other structures still populate the area --so much so that Raleigh resident George Smart has found no end in cataloging just the residential structures worthy of note. But after Wake County demolished its Social Services Building in 1998 it left the First Federal Building as the only well-dressed representative of that time.

image

The history of the making of the building remains elusive. While the drawings are presently archived with the State of North Carolina, little knowledge exists about its Architect, Howard Musick.  What we do know is that the firm he worked for, the Bank Building Corporation in St. Louis, offered services to meet the needs of the client in whatever particular style the bank required. Musick would have likely been conversant in many styles and, given the rarity of the BBC’s client base requesting a Modern building, this may be his only extant structure built in this style.

Its rarity not forsaken, the First Federal Building has garnered great appeal as evidenced in various public outlets. Is there some architectural connoisseurship at play here?  Some abstract, elitist appreciation of a building from a time we can no longer relate to?  Or perhaps it is as simple as for the way it has become a part of our downtown: an iconic landmark and a good neighbor. Its modest scale relates more to historic Raleigh structures like the Briggs Hardware Building or the adjacent Lawyer’s Building.  Its windows also recall historic proportions without superficially copying them. A lively dance of colored panels is more painterly and mural-like than a stolid building wall.  It should be noted that the new Convention Center will have a high tech, kinetic version of these panels when it opens later this year. Really just a glorified ventilation louver, it calls upon our desire to create something energetic and unique to make our places special. As a counterpoint to the blue panels, white marble adorns the Salisbury street façade which originally provided a lavish backdrop for the First Federal’s dramatic, razor-like sign.  Softened by the stone’s veining, the panels are at the same time sensual and commanding. They defy one’s intuition that heavy stone must be supported by terra firma.  It floats, as if weightless, above a narrow band of windows, freeing the building from the ground, opening it up to light and air.

image

The building’s entry is set directly on the street: intimate and approachable.  It is protected by the building’s low, broad canopy which wraps the corner and shelters all passersby.  Its effect is to create an outdoor room along Salisbury Street. The canopy is so low one can easily jump and hang off of it. It is so deep that it provides respite from the sun or rain.  In good weather, citizens are found sitting and conversing adding humanity to an otherwise vacant stretch of sidewalk.  In rain, the canopy is a gracious umbrella, offering shelter from the storm regardless of one’s intentions to do business within. The room becomes equal parts lobby, break room and a box seat for an unfolding sidewalk drama. The internal drama of couples getting marriage licenses or parcels being registered is revealed through the broad expanse of glass, letting natural light pour in with the view. Conversely the buildings occupants look out to connect with life on the street.  Everyone is in on the act and nobody is left out.

image

Its most iconic feature is a whimsical civic gift, common to bank buildings. This digital version proclaims the local time and temperature.  In an age where Weather.com’s local average temperature at RDU Airport is “good enough”, it’s a reminder that being here and now --at the corner of Salisbury and Martin Streets-- will always be more real than virtual.

image

Within a year of its construction, JFK would ask citizens to consider what they could contribute to the country rather than the reverse.  Likewise, the First Federal Building asks one to seek meaning within its simple details rather than treating us like children waiting to be tucked in with a fairytale bedtime story.  A standard complaint of Modern Architecture is that it is cold and unfeeling.  Yet, in its unwillingness to adorn itself with recognizable patterns from the past, it remains forever open to possibility-- never exclusively Greek or Roman, Gothic or Baroque—and always waiting to be interpreted. Given the ever increasing diversity of our citizenry, the First Federal Building offers a universal voice that is perhaps more relevant to this time than ever before. 

The implication here is that we all possess a deeper understanding of Architecture’s power beyond the superficialities of appearance. This is what ultimately makes this building remarkable and gives it substance.  Put another way, beyond how a building may appear, Architecture serves man’s desires to create meaningful places that enrich our lives. In this case, enrichment comes with a little bit of work, but ultimately it is much more rewarding.

All photos courtesy of New Raleigh, except night photo by Goodnight, Raleigh!
Construction Drawing courtesy of the NC State Archives

Welcome to New Raleigh. We welcome your participation in the ongoing discussion. If you are new we invite you to register with our site. With registration you can upload a picture, message other users, and comment more easily. If you want to keep up with the site, subscribe to our RSS feed or get emailed every time we post.

  • Jim02/15 08:56 AM

    JZ, this is a lovely encomium for a beautiful building.  I still can’t believe it’s going to be torn down.  Especially to make way for what’s replacing it.

  • RaleighRob02/15 09:25 AM

    Great article.  I agree it’s a crying shame they’re gonna knock it down.  There are plenty of crappy dilapidated empty buildings on various blocks of downtown that really should see the wrecking ball instead of this unique structure!

  • Dana02/15 10:49 AM

    This building is hideous, but I hate to see it go. I’d like for downtown to be a big collection of architecture of different styles.

    Pragmatically it makes no sense to keep this building. The county certainly needs to space planned in the new building and the costs are extremely high to get this building up to “code” (ie modifications to the building so it is healthier and more accessible to all people regardless of need - this is an interesting conundrum - big-hearted, big-government liberals have established laws that make previous creativity obsolete.)

    Nevertheless, there are too many empty lots in and around downtown Raleigh to go tearing stuff down just yet.

  • rsc02/15 11:03 AM

    > Pragmatically it makes no sense to keep this building.

    More precisely, it makes no sense for THE COUNTY to keep this building. They can’t justify renovating the building because it complicates the project. It’s easier for them just to knock it down.

    But they could sell it. They won’t, because it means they won’t have control over the entire block anymore. But a private developer would be much more able to justify renovations than the County is.

  • brian_M02/15 11:46 AM

    Hideous? I guess you’d like it better if it was wrapped in cake decorating like North Hills, the definition of gorgeous. I’d like to see the longevity of anything over there vs. this kind of architecture. That place will NEVER be considered iconic or important.

  • 15002/15 12:06 PM

    It pains me deeply to agree with Dana, but I think the building is pretty ugly, too.  I’m not an architect, so I don’t look at the building as deeply as many of you do, so take my opinion for what it’s worth.

    Also, I don’t see how North Hills has anything to do with an opinion on this building.

  • Dana02/15 12:22 PM

    brian_M,
    I never mentioned North Hills, and I have never said such.

    150,
    Sorry to cause you such great pain.

  • salley02/15 12:53 PM

    In case you don’t already know the County is having public meetings about this project. If you’d like to speak for or against the demolition I’d suggest attending. You’ll be able to speak directly to the project team and the folks making this decision. Did anybody attend the meeting downtown earlier this week? If not there are still 2 left- in Knightdale and Cary.

    From wakegov.com:

    The public meetings will be held from 5 to 7 p.m.

    They are scheduled for the following dates and locations:

    February 11, 2008
    Wake County Public Safety Center
    330 S. Salisbury Street
    Raleigh, NC 27601

    February 12, 2008
    Northern Regional Center (NRC)
    350 Holding Avenue
    Wake Forest, NC 27587

    February 18, 2008
    Knightdale Town Hall
    950 Steeple Square Court
    Knightdale, NC 27545

    February 19, 2008
    Wake County West Regional Library
    4000 Louis Stephens Road
    Cary, NC 27519

  • brian_M02/15 05:26 PM

    They aren’t going to give a crap about anybody speaking against the building’s demolition, they have big plans for that lot, another large fug annex of Wake County’s office buildings/courts/jails. They ought to put stuff like that in a scrubby field or something. Downtown needs to hang onto the character is has, no matter if somebody thinks a building like this is hideous. It was a product of its time, and is a singular example of such in the city center.

  • Dawson02/19 12:35 PM

    I agree with this article, but let’s take it a step further.  We need to replace all the buildings downtown that are more indicative of Raleigh’s history, since that seems to be of paramount importance.  I mean, when it comes down to it, they tore something down to put up the focus of this article.  Maybe a nice muddy parking lot for wagons.

    I was thinking that we could knock down the Progress Energy building and put back that Tobacco barn which used to be such a proud symbol of NC’s heritage.  Or maybe a log cabin.  There is no reason when there is plenty of land to develop outside the city limits that Wake County should place their building there, well except for the fact that message boards everywhere would explode with complaints of sprawl and not having a centralized county organism.

  • Cydney02/19 08:56 PM

    I went to the public meeting at the West Regional Library earlier tonight.  There was no project team with whom to speak about concerns of design or sustainability.  There was a rumor that an OBA representative was in attendance, but it was otherwise a couple of gentlemen from Wake County and from Barnhill there to justify how the County will be spending taxpayers’ money.  No one, really, with any place in the decision making.

    Problems I noticed were the bare bones LEED certification checklist, an unrealistic budget and a lack of natural light in the office spaces.  Passage through metal detectors will be required at both main-level entrances.  The Register of Deeds space will be relocated to the McDowell Street side, well above street level and completely devoid of the urban connection JZ described so well.

  • Lewis Wilson02/20 09:09 AM

    I love modern architecture—but that building seriously makes me shudder. I can’t/don’t want to imagine what it looks like on the inside with the blue - are those “windows” ? that being said I wouldn’t mind seeing it renovated as opposed to demolished.

  • RaleighRob02/20 11:08 AM

    At this point I’m kinda resigned to the fact they’re gonna demolish it, even though I think all it ever needed was a good renovation.

    At the very least I hope they save and re-use/recycle all that marble!  (Would be a huge waste otherwise.) Maybe give it away to someone to do a public art project?

  • JZ03/09 01:39 PM

    A quick read for those still interested in why the preservation of this single remaining example is important for Raleigh:  http://www.aia.org/aiarchitect/thisweek08/0307/0307t_fixler.cfm

  • Christopher Triplett03/24 09:34 AM

    For all of those who call it ugly:

    Just imagine it were brand new and full of condos. 

    Interesting, right?

    -CJT

    http://ginkotron.com




Remember my information for next time I comment

Send me an email of follow-up comments?