First Listen: The Avett Brothers’ I and Love and You

The Avett Brothers in less than 140 characters.

June, 10, 2009, by Jedidiah

Advertise on NR

In two months, Concord, N.C. quartet The Avett Brothers will release I and Love and You, their sixth studio album and first for American Recordings, the Sony imprint run by production mogul Rick Rubin. A major label, a major project, a major timeline: After more than a year in the making, I and Love and You is now in its final stages of completion, having gone through recording in studios on two coasts, mixes by multiple sets of ears and—finally—a series of mastering attempts that try to render the record ready for what’s likely to be an enormous audience.

On Monday afternoon, a not-quite-finished copy of the album arrived at the offices of the Independent Weekly in Durham. Later that night, Independent Weekly Music Editor Grayson Currin and New Raleigh Downtown Editor Jedidiah Gant gathered in Raleigh to listen to the work-in-progress fidior the first time and offer their instant impressions via their personal Twitter accounts. We’ve gathered those moment-by-moment tweets into roughly edited form, presenting them as a generally obnoxious, sometimes humorous and fairly informative guide to what you’ll expect when the band drops its major-label introduction August 11.

Just to be clear, both listeners love the record and, 48 hours later, consider it to be the most evolved and perhaps best work by the band yet. Also of note: The title track, “Kick Drum Heart” and “It Goes On and On” might make this band awfully famous. (intro text by Grayson Currin)

And the tracklist for the record in question:

1. I and Love and You
2. January Wedding
3. Head Full of Doubt, Road Full of Promise
4. And it Spread
5. The Perfect Space
6. Ten Thousand Words
7. Kick Drum Heart
8. Laundry Room
9. Ill with Want
10. Tin Man
11. Slight Figure of Speech
12. It Goes On and On
13. Incomplete and Insecure

And the tweets…

Jedidiah Gant: Album title: I and Love and You (Not Final)...but without the Not Final.

Jedidiah Gant: Piano begins it.

Grayson Currin: The title track is the opener, “I and Love and You,” sounding like the live version so far. Nice strings pealing from beneath verse two.

Jedidiah Gant: Jumping tracks and never returning to Brooklyn… Piano gains drums.

Jedidiah Gant: Next layer: violin and Seth (post Scott’s intro).

Jedidiah Gant: First song: Highway already mentioned.

Jedidiah Gant: Orchestra and Brooklyn collide.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy never seen this song live….oddly?!

Jedidiah Gant: “3 words: I and love and you.” Gorgeous beginning to the album.

Grayson Currin: Like what the drums do during chorus two, picking up to build toward the turnaround, like Joe Jackson etc. Interesting harmonies ~3:30.

Jedidiah Gant: Thickness indeed!

Jedidiah Gant: Song two: banjo enters.

Grayson Currin: Was that a Farfisa headed into the last chorus? Really beautiful version of that song. Banjo and Guitar and Seth open “January Wedding.”

Jedidiah Gant: “January Wedding” reminds me that The Avetts would make a Great kids album (Disclaimer: I have a pregnant wife.)

Jedidiah Gant: First sound of Bob’s bass comes in nicely between breaks.

Grayson Currin: Whoa, end rhyme using Audrey Hepburn. Banjo has a nice tone hear, ringing and bright. Finger slides on strings of both. Bob snapping deep.

Grayson Currin: A song about the renewal a food lover can bring? Classic Avett mid-tempo acoustic tune in the making. Nothing exceptional, but good for the n00bs.

Jedidiah Gant: I keep hearing Fletwood Mac. Am I wrong or silly or?

Grayson Currin: @formotion I can fet with you on the Fleetwood comparison, particularly in the way it’s all layered classically, all things pouring into one.

Grayson Currin: Surprising drum/piano/string clang on No. 3, “Darkness.” “Your life doesn’t change by whoever’s elected,” sings Scott. Holy shit, a Hammond!

Jedidiah Gant: “Darkness” starts with an exclamation mark in the form of Scott & Orchestrated soundscape that jumps above trees. Like Crouching Tiger film.

Grayson Currin: “Avetts Go prog.” Kidding, but interesting turnaround. Scott and Seth’s interplay with piano and drums is fertile ground. Organrockbuild!!!

Jedidiah Gant: Piano, keys, and organ introduce a sound not heard from these guys. “I hear a Darkness.”

Jedidiah Gant: Is this the organ that Byrne set up in that building in Brooklyn? I and love and Byrne. “And it Spread.” Drums smack face. Spreading in a minor chord place.

Grayson Currin: You might have heard this one live, “And It Spread.” Interesting harmony choices, Scott shooting through back of refrain. Three-piece chug.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy nope…not this one either…Man, I’m out of it. That’s what I get for hatin on DMB.

Jedidiah Gant: And it Spread….groovy tone…“Colorshow” with more energy and step and Seth.

Grayson Currin: If you believe your Avetts should be a string band, you’ll hate the way they handle the stringiest number here. MARCHING DRUMS, DUDEZ!!

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy Grammys, Avetts, Marching band. Radiohead, Outkast: “Eat your heart out.”

Grayson Currin: This song’s shifted a lot, thanks to the drums. Nice little picking flurry at the end. Now “Friends.” Saw this debuted in sold-out PDX.

Jedidiah Gant: “Friends.” A common Avett theme….

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy I like that you’ve heard all of these and I’ve heard none. I have history; you have current knowledge

Grayson Currin: Last time I heard this song, I saw a grown man cry. Sort of tingling hearing it again. Maybe that’s the diabetes speaking, though. Oops.

Jedidiah Gant: I hear Rubin loud and clear now.

Grayson Currin: This goofy mid-section is so totally awesome: Crowded House + Madness + ZZ Top + whatthefuckever, Scott nailing drums and shouting. Oh boy.

Jedidiah Gant: Friends has those Oh What a Nightmare tempo and style changes, with a little Rebel Yell

Jedidiah Gant: Joe Kwon now has a prime place in the band. How about the No Doubt horn players, though?

Grayson Currin: Scott and Seth, trading lines about friends and family and aging. Totally kind of touching, but balanced nicely with the raucous midsection.

Jedidiah Gant: Is Bob gonna sing on this album or is he cut off?

Grayson Currin: Acoustics wrapping around each other on “Ten Thousand Words.” Doubled vocals—>slight canon tease. Pick it, boy. Organ beneath!!

Jedidiah Gant: Finally a little Seth Guitar lick in “10,000 words.” Organ layered behind.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy Scott playing Organ?

Jedidiah Gant: Fleetwood Mac again.

Jedidiah Gant: Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young and I and Love and You.

Grayson Currin: This sort of sounds like “Going to California,” no? Organ peeling off acoustic Guitars in the high and low register. Love the slipstreams.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy “Cali” indeed…once again the Oh What a Nigtmare sound, too.

Jedidiah Gant: Keep hearing lots of Weight of Lies leftovers. One my favs.

Grayson Currin: Scott’s kind of jive-talking five minutes into “10,000,” a song that goes absolutely nowhere, but in a way that is totally preparation for

Jedidiah Gant: “Kick Drum Heart”...They Might be Giants, anyone????? Popopppopoppoopopppoppoopppopppplpppopppppopppppppp smile.

Grayson Currin: “Kick-Drum Heart.” People will chastise Rick Rubin for “forcing” a pop song. He keeps it ragged, though (nb: harmonies), and it works…

Jedidiah Gant: Kids album…see TMBG. My hearts like a Toy Piano.

Jedidiah Gant: Maybe they could borrow No Doubt’s horns section, actually.

Jedidiah Gant: “Heart” song for remixing

Grayson Currin: The slow down is a little less epic than it is live, but that makes sense, I suppose. Finally, at the end, we get Seth screaming.

Jedidiah Gant: “Kick drum” at the end could be cut.

Grayson Currin: Oh fuck, “Laundry Room.” FACEBOOKSTATUSMESSAGECORNUCOPIACOMEGETSOMEYOUKNOWYOUWANTIT. I love everything this song is about. Accordion!

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy points at Laundry room. Rubin’s influence very apparent

Grayson Currin: Post-chorus for this is great. Bob’s entry is well-timed on this. He’s been a bit quiet throughout, but always present, it seems. STATUS!

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy thinking the same about Bobby Crawford….Giddy-up.

Jedidiah Gant: Burning lyrics and breaking tired old routines….Avetts doing this indeed. H.G. Wells?

Grayson Currin: I just updated my Facebook status 17 times in three minutes thanks to “Laundry Room.” Hey, is that joke a “tired old routine” yet? Ouch.

Grayson Currin: Holy Foggy Mountain Breakdown are these boys from N.C. playing that bluegrass mess with that violin and stuff? Unexpected conclusion.

Jedidiah Gant: Maybe they should score a western movie…set in a laundry room?

Grayson Currin: Now to “Sick With Want.” Piano and acoustic guitar waltz that builds. Big choral harmonies here. female on back-up vox. “Jess L.M.?,”

Jedidiah Gant: “Sick with Want.” Definitely an Avett layered phrase, lyric, philosophy.

Jedidiah Gant: I knew the would get to the traditional drum beat at some point….“Sick with Want” is it.

Jedidiah Gant: There’s the chorus of women I’ve been waiting for….note to Avetts, export this to other songs.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy I hear Use Your Illusion I and II? Maybe they could swim with Dolphins.

Grayson Currin: This songs certainly pretty, but—on first listen and three minutes in—I’m kind of ready to head on into what’s next. Nice bro+bro end…

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy waltz Good call…reminds me of my favorite song by Elliot Smith.

Jedidiah Gant: “Tin Man:” lots of old Avett sound with new Rubin rainbows! ()*&)($*&

Grayson Currin: “Tin Man,” bros! Pretty straightforward with the live version, but there’s a difference in the strings. Joe and/or Bob bowing discord?

Jedidiah Gant: Unidentified ‘bowing’ sound verified as possibly Joe. I think it’s a saw…

Grayson Currin: Interesting choices that this song takes sonically, considering the spacing around the drums and how the strings move to/fro the song…

Jedidiah Gant: Seth has his way with this one

Jedidiah Gant: Still unidentified sound….rewinding

Jedidiah Gant: Trombone is latest theory

Grayson Currin: Is that a horn on “Tin Man”? First horn appearance? Good ol’ bros intro on “Slight Figure of Speech.” Rolling Stone: wrong. Avetts rap!

Grayson Currin: “A jet plane and a big idea!” Facebook statusez, y’all. Generous pop harmonies beneath this one, plus mildly distorto bass from Bob Crawford

Jedidiah Gant: “Slight Figure of Speech:” 50s sound I’ve been missing on this album

Grayson Currin: Pretty sure they skip over this reversed-and-skipped vocal part in the middle of “Slight Figure” live? Does that mean it’s a slight figure?

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy Avetts Rap indeed… Punk version of Talk in Indolence

Jedidiah Gant: Ahhhhhhhhh ahhhhhhh. Ahhhhhhh

Jedidiah Gant: Another odd ending. Chord, chord, chord.

Grayson Currin: Here’s the hit, they think: “It Goes On.” “I give it a week until someone makes a Ben Folds comparison.” —S. Griffith. Self-fulfillment!

Jedidiah Gant: It Goes On. @currincy says it’s the hit. Does have that catchy rhythm

Jedidiah Gant: Tingly piano and layering of voices. Poppiopopppoppppppp. Man, Seth’s voice is ridiculously amazing now.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy yes! Avetts Fold Five.

Grayson Currin: Hey, this song sounds just like that other guy from Chapel Hill with the piano and the song about knocking his ol’ lady up, amirite? OK!

Grayson Currin: I love this tune and it’s switches in time. It reminds me of being in high school in a convertible in the summer, which I never did…

Jedidiah Gant: Gimme Back my black tshirt

Jedidiah Gant: Last song: “Incomplete and Insecure.” Slow and waltz again

Grayson Currin: Last tune…OK here we Go: “Incomplete and Insecure.”  They’ve played this at soundchecks.

Grayson Currin: “I can tell people that this success is a direct reflection of me, but…” I’d like to think this is subtitled “For Dolphus, For Now…”

Jedidiah Gant: Building up. Will it be a grande finale? Piano seems to say so.

Grayson Currin: This is an interesting end to the record, Given its mid-to-up tempo, but I have a feeling the strings will take us out. Let’s see…

Jedidiah Gant: I see them scoring a Broadway musical next.

Grayson Currin: Oh, text painting at the end: “I haven’t finished a thing in my life/ don’t feel like starting now.” Song ends sans beat/chord resolution.

Jedidiah Gant: Slow ending. No grande finale. Not Fourth of July. Just the end.

Jedidiah Gant: @currincy would have liked more of a longer strings walk out

Grayson Currin: Thought: I enjoyed this album very much and I will recommend it to a friend. If this were a fast-food chain, I would supersize. Dig???

Grayson Currin: I’m interested to hear Team Avetts’ thoughts on the production of Rick Rubin. Though this is the Avetts, there are some ambitious ideas

Jedidiah Gant: Very operatic approach to an album, especially considering they are from and live on the back roads of North Carolina

Grayson Currin: And the diehards could really hate them because they’re, well, different. But it’s, on first listen, smartly played/made/considered!!!

Grayson Currin: I’m glad they didn’t try to recap the “old charms of The Avetts” as a potential introduction to a bigger audience. This is not reverse.

Jedidiah Gant: Another great step forward for the Avetts. Each album is a stepping stone on a staircase to fame. On that note, I look forward to buying it.

Jedidiah Gant: Definitely the most mature album thus far. Look forward to next listen. This concludes the Avett Tweet fest.

Find the same tweet fest at The Independent Weekly

New Raleigh stories about I and Love and You:

Avett Brothers I and Love and You Details Emerge

More I and Love and You Details Emerge

The Avett Brothers Release I and Love and You Tracklist

Read More

Music, Other posts by Jedidiah.


The Avett BrothersIndependent WeeklyIndyWeek


  • Tweeter
    06/10 07:43 PM


  • nowthatswhaticallpretentious
    06/11 10:57 AM

    If I never see another line by line description of a record as it plays again it will be too soon.

  • Wow
    06/11 06:43 PM

    So you felt the need to compare every track to something else? Ben Folds, They Might Be Giants, Fleetwood Mac.

    Also, worst line ever….. borrow the horns from No Doubt?

    You two aren’t allowed to review music anymore. Ever. Reminds me of….

  • matt
    06/11 08:03 PM

    They’re OK, but in no way deserve such ass-kissing! Where is the content addressed? I expect nothing but another album of lame love songs.

    You’re “wrong or silly or”!

  • Rontington
    06/12 06:06 PM

    this hype is unprecedented [these guys’ songs are not in the same league as yer Morning Jacket or yer Wilco, but, hey… Go Team!]

    is it because they’re “local”?

    as a skeptic, I’m on high alert, though: how many remixes over how many months in how many studios on how many coasts??AND multiple masterings?!
    I sense the meddling hand of The Industry is working over-overtime pulling some strings here, folks. 

    I WILL give it a listen though… eventually.

  • Bad Idea
    06/12 06:59 PM

    Hyper-tweeting is for the birds.

  • tall pines
    06/18 02:16 AM

    The first outlet with an advance copy and we get tweets?  I suppose there are a few insightful nuggets in there, but I wish you guys would have done a proper review.

  • tall pines
    06/18 02:22 AM

    Eaasy Rontington. 
    The Avetts, MMJ, and Wilco are apples, oranges, and bananas.  They are completely different experiences.  Just relax and love all 3 “in so many different ways”

Share Your Thoughts

Commenting is not available in this channel entry.