Jesse Benjamin Friday, March 05, 2010

School Bored? Let’s look ahead.

School Bored? Let’s look ahead.

Let’s get real here, and I mean Dr. Phil real. Everybody’s right on this thing. You don’t want to put your kid on a bus at 6 to get to school at 8? Entirely reasonable. You want to live in a community that doesn’t facilitate having some schools of affluent kids and others of abjectly poor kids? You have approached this issue with remarkable clearness of mind and reached a sensible conclusion.

Okay, both sides are right, so what’s next? May I suggest a duel: Margiotta v. Burns, High Noon, Fayetteville Street? No, that’s barbaric and illegal. We don’t solve disagreements that way, especially not in sophisticated, wired, bestest place to live, Wake County. How about everyone just take sides and start name calling and ascribing base motivations to the opposition?  No again, as that would be a childish waste of energy and never lead to a resolu….

I’ll be damned, that’s right where we are, aren’t we? You disagree with me and, well, you suck, that’s what. It’s a good thing this isn’t Detroit or Newark or any place that has real problems, because we’d probably all just lay down and die. We were all dripping wet with Hope and Change a little while back. Maybe we were just hoping those idiots would change their minds and agree with us (RIMSHOT!). Doesn’t work that way. By the time you start caring about issues, you’ve had your worldview shaped by strong forces and aren’t going to be swayed by much. And you don’t go looking to be swayed, either. Do you want to have your mind changed if your news intake consists of Olbermann, Daily Show and Huffington Post? Same for the other side. A daily diet of Limbaugh, OReilly and Drudge isn’t opening you up to hear all sides of an issue.

It’s time for some healing. Let’s find some common ground and admit that everybody’s right, and also that everybody’s being a dick. (And since I don’t have a dog in this fight, as you’ll see, let me go ahead and announce that the biggest dicks are all those who want Obama to ram healthcare down the Republicans’ throats and then scream about the Wake County School Board majority pursuing their agenda) Now everybody repent for their dickish ways and let’s approach this again, but from a different angle.

What are we fighting about anyway? Wake County is one of the best school districts in the country, we’re told. But isn’t that kind of like being the the tallest building in Kansas? Does it really mean anything? Looks like to me we are calling each others racists and animals over an approach to “education” that will be outdated in the next 10 years or so. Every other part of your life is technology driven, individualized, and customizable. We’re ripping each other about where we send our kids to get information when information is available everywhere, and free(!) for the most part.

Here’s a brainstorm for ya, maybe our concept of school is outdated and we should be looking ahead instead of rehashing the 1960s. Seems like a area with a high concentration of Phds and a throbbing Creative Class would be looking forward to the next evolution in education, begging for it, using their time, talent and treasure to bring it about. Because if we really want to compete in a global economy, and we really want to be progressive, a 1940s, industrial-style education system isn’t the way to do it.

You don’t want to hear that though and let me tell you why. If you’re a suburban, no-more-busing advocate, a rethinking of education could mean an end to what public school really means for you: free babysitter. When education fully realizes its commodity status and new distribution systems develop around, it won’t make sense to send kids away from home all day to get it. That means you have to find other childcare arrangements or, gasp, you have to stay with the kids yourself! That means quitting your job, which will mess with your finances, which means you may have to give up weekends at the lake on the Sea-Doo. Apocalypse!

And you there, in the Prius, bad news for you, too. You remember the poors you wanted to mingle with the rich kids? They’re still going to be around. And you won’t be able to say you’re an “advocate for diversity” as a cover for your non-action. You won’t be able to pass the buck of people in your city living in oppressive poverty to a group of racist suburbanites who only love Target and other white people. It’ll be on you to help change things. You’ll be expected to get down to Walnut Terrace in South Park to help the kids with their work. Maybe watch them while their parents work late, stuff like that. This will cut back on the time you spend at Morning Times and Busy Bee. Apocalypse!

It’s easy to disagree, it’s easy to spew venom. It’s hard to create, hard to vision something better than accepted norms. But if we’re such a smart, creative place, we should be doing just that. Let me quote the great philosopher Donald Draper, who may only be fictional and exist on a small cable network, but understands life better than most: “Move forward”. If education and kids are important, let’s quit bitching and get to work on what’s next, not what was.

Related Posts:

Overheard: Beverly Perdue
School Board Puts Superintendent Del Burns on Administrative Leave
Wake County School Board Reinstates Segregated Schooling, I Mean Busing

Tagged: Wake County School Board

Read More: Politics , Other posts by Jesse Benjamin.

  • revolu
    03/05 09:34 AM

    Good article.

  • matt w
    03/05 09:43 AM

    This article is amazing.  In a good way.

  • 150
    03/05 09:57 AM

    Um, so the point of this was what again?  Maybe I didn’t read carefully enough, but the rant seems to fall victm to what’s written in the last paragraph.  More “dickish” venom and nothing constructive towards a solution. 
    Also, some of your starting points are flawed, incorrect, and objectionable.  They also highlight part of the basis for what you’re thesis is about.  Plopping everyone in two conflicting groups, making generalizations and then attaching stereotypical characteristics to them. 
    Why not start over and follow the suggestion in the last sentence of paragraph four.  Have it on our desk by COB.

  • JohnBrownsBooty
    03/05 10:40 AM

    where’d my previous comment go? I tried to post it and it said that I was “not authorized to perform this action”.

    Oooh…wheee…what up with that?

  • JohnBrownsBooty
    03/05 10:56 AM

    thoughtful, but the piece espouses the common error of attributing equal validity to any and all points of view.

    Listen: some ideas are better than others, and some people are more wrong than others. The debate here isn’t an amoral one, however immoral the behaviour of the school board majority might be—note I say their behaviour, not their beliefs.

    They are those motivated by the shrill voices of a vocal suburban minority motivated by convenience, first and foremost, and by a small cabal of political power mongers secondly. Are they racists? Doubtful, though they probably have the support of the racists. Are they segregationists? No, and I think calling them segregationists and racists demeans the weight of their opposition.

    They’re not racist segregationists—they’re people who know that their policies will result in segregation (class and race based, in that order) and an overall reduction in the quality of the school system…it’s not their goal that these things happen, it’s that they just don’t care that they will. I think that’s an important difference.

    Finally, brushing off this conflict as though A) both sides have precisely equally valid claims and priorities, and B) that every kid in the near future utopia will be educated by a Kindle and Mac Book is both superficial and fatuous.

  • KC Ramsay
    03/05 11:01 AM

    Well said. I hope this gets picked up elsewhere.

  • sco2ts
    03/05 12:09 PM

    150,
    Amen!

  • spookyjon
    03/05 12:23 PM

    At the risk of repeating what’s already been said, the mere presence of two sides to a debate doesn’t mean both sides are equally valid.  Long bus rides are no fun, but they’re a small price to pay for the benefits of Wake County’s system.  Poor students do much better, good students do no worse, and the primary cost is a pain in the ass bus ride for some students.  Our school system is used as a case study all over the country as an example of how to do things right.

    While I appreciate the sentiment of the post, it’s honestly one of the dumbest things I’ve ever seen on New Raleigh.  And that includes The All Black Van.

  • RA
    03/05 12:29 PM

    “Poor students do much better, good students do no worse, and the primary cost is a pain in the ass bus ride for some students.” - spookyjon

    That is what the PR machine tells you, but look at the facts.  There is no support for the claim you just made.

    Sorry for the repost, but this is important:

    From - http://www.wcpss.net/evaluation-research/reports/2009/0931hs-graduation09.pdf

    On time graduation rate:
    Asian   88.30%
    Hispanic 51.10%
    Black   63.40%
    White   89.40%

    So this new board is going to cause inequality in our schools?

    Same report, on time graduation rate again:
    Group   Wake   NC
    Asian   88.30%  83.60%
    Hispanic 51.10%  58.90%
    Black   63.40%  63.20%
    White   89.40%  77.70%

    The new board is the problem?  Wake County has a larger gap in ethnic graduation rates than the state as a whole.

    Want to claim that the policies are allowed to address race so that isn’t fair?  OK, same source, four year grad rate again:

    Group   Wake   NC
    F&R   54.20%  61.80%
    LEP   38.90%  52.10%
    All   78.40%  71.70%

    Wake does worse for than the state average for the higher risk populations, but covers it up in the total by excelling with those who aren’t at seen as at risk.

    “Our school system is used as a case study all over the country as an example of how to do things right.”

    If a district graduation rate gap between rich and poor of 24% in a state that averages just under 10% is “how to do things right”, I’d rather be wrong.

  • JeffS
    03/05 01:15 PM

    RA, how many times are you going to cut and paste the same comment?

    Maybe it’s time to come up with an original thought.

  • RA
    03/05 01:22 PM

    JeffS

    That was one paste, for which I apologized.  What original thoughts do you have on the subject? 
    “Fat white women in big cookie-cutter houses will not continue to represent me.”
    “IMO, you’ve create the problem you’re complaining about and should STFU.”

    When we can expect more brilliance like this?

    Here is an original thought for you: get some facts or STFU.  So far you have nothing to contribute but the same tired talking points sprinkled with the occasional invective.

  • Bill M
    03/05 02:04 PM

    And RA, let me tell you my real world experience with Wake County Schools.  My wife and I volunteer often, as do many of the parents at our local magnet elementary school.  My wife assists the teacher in the classroom, often twice a week, every week.  The teacher has the volunteers work, not with their own children, but with the kids that are getting no help at home.  Whose parents don’t speak english, much less know how to teach their kids how to read English.  I also know parents who are mentoring at-risk children at this school, whose families cannot provide support. Please explain how that is detrimental to that population and how they would be better served being ghettoized into a school without those resources.

  • JohnBrownsBooty
    03/05 02:16 PM

    Which of the new school board majority have any education experience, in the classroom or otherwise?

    coincidence?

    Not to the people who claim education should be run by businessmen and other types who fail 90% of the time.

    Then again, I’ve been going to the doctor my entire life…I demand to set AMA board policy!

  • Dan
    03/05 02:46 PM

    “you have to stay with the kids yourself!”

    I wish you were anywhere near right. It’d be a better world, but that line right there just shows how ridiculously out of touch you are with the reality of today.

    First off, I dont think 40% (if not way higher) of the American male workforce could afford a mortgage, standard minimum utility bills, and food if they are having to also pay for their spouses health insurance. Family plans where I work, which are required for plans that even include only one female, are over $600 month. My wife works because of that alone right now. We have no cable tv, no home phones, eat in, and still couldnt afford for her to stay home right now with the extra $400 deduction from my current salary. And I think its clear that unless at least one Democrat can prove able grows some balls in the next 10 years, which I doubt, health insurance is only getting more expensive.

    If you think there a chance in hell of society moving to single income households, you are two things: 1. A hopeless idealist that I admire, and, 2, completely ignorant of reality in America and completely unqualified to write puiblically about such things.

    Seriously, go live in the real world. We built ourselves this two household income grave in the 70’s and 80’s. Prices aren’t dropping just because we’ve learned that its better to keep our kids at home.

    Second, ever heard of the NEA? Do you think for one goddam second their lobbying power is going to allow the abandoning of public schools anywhere near the next 10 to 20 years? Are you f’ing kidding me?

    The worst part of this article is it comes across pompous. Like you know this to be true when you don’t even know what time it is or even what galaxy you are living in. Nap time is over buddy. Time to wake up. Real answers demand people understanding the reality of the problems we face.

  • JohnBrownsBooty
    03/05 02:59 PM

    “Second, ever heard of the NEA? Do you think for one goddam second their lobbying power is going to allow the abandoning of public schools anywhere near the next 10 to 20 years?”

    ever hear of a strawman chronically propped up by public school haters as predictably as the sun comes up?

    the NEA is:

    -poor, which greatly diminishes their lobbying power. Greatly.
    -just something some of you are taught to parrot when you hear about public schools and why you should demean and work against them.
    -weak.
    -made up of a very small minority of the nation’s teachers.
    -utterly committed to mediocrity. utterly.
    -did I mention poor and weak, ergo little to no lobbying power?

    You’re like listening to some neoCon MadLibs, broham. weak.

  • RG
    03/05 03:24 PM

    HEY, you’re right, there shouldn’t be a tired left/right, Apex parent/NAACP debate. Because the community zones system screws them both. The new board majority cynically promised suburban parents the world and have no chance of delivering. WCPSS is at 92% capacity right now with no more schools being built, and the new board wants to lock everyone in a “community” zone they can’t be re-assigned out of for diversity OR to alleviate overcrowding(which is why Deborah Prickett’s son got re-assigned, by the way)
    They didn’t tell you that part…
    Massive overcrowding = more money for private & charter schools.

  • Dan
    03/05 03:29 PM

    You know, just saying the NEA is poor on a blog doesn’t make it true, right? Their 2010 budget exceeds 350 million dollars.

    I think another reality check is needed.

    I laugh at the neocon reference. I wear red, and not just because I went to NC State. In my dreams, one day we’ll have real family values like Europe, with single payer insurance, 2 years paid maternity leave WITH mandatory 6 months paternity leave, and proper progressive tax scale.

    In my waking hours though, I know we can’t get there by ignoring reality.

  • RA
    03/05 03:30 PM

    Bill M,
    “Please explain how that is detrimental to that population and how they would be better served being ghettoized into a school without those resources. “

    Please show me where I said they would be. (Hint, I didn’t)

    Don’t mistake may lack of support for previous policies for support of the currently presented alternative.

    RG,
    The capacity numbers are complete BS.  They aren’t based on any objective measure and are used for political gains.  All you have to do is look at the stated capacity changes of buildings that have occurred when there was neither a change in mobile capacity nor class size mandates.  When the plan is to reassign kids to a school, the capacity goes up.  When they need to justify year round, the capacity goes down.

  • JeffS
    03/05 03:55 PM

    “Massive overcrowding = more money for private & charter schools.”


    And that’s the goal of the money behind these people. They’re not trying to fix the system.

  • Justonething
    03/06 06:24 PM

    Great piece! I agree completely that parents hand their children over to the school system and expect the system to hand them back in 12 years clean, shiny and ready to go to UNC and be a Doctor. You are also correct that Wake county is behind in integrating technology into education - but the state as a whole is making some progress. Anyone interested in a “blended” education model should check out the North Carolina Virtual Public School (http://www.ncvps.org) free to all students - all they need is a school or a school system to support them.

  • papmerstato
    03/07 09:44 AM

    CupidoMeet Chatta Invita e Guadagna il primo sito italiano di incontri che ti fa guadagnare

                        Ciao a tutti!
    Oggi vogliamo spiegarvi dettagliatamente come funziona il guadagnare soldi reali …Partiamo dall’inizio: tutti i siti attualmente online di incontri, offrono un area webmaster che permette di guadagnare solo ed esclusivamente ai possessori di almeno un sito web. Da qui nasce la nostra idea
    Noi ci siamo chiesti:
    Se una persona vuole guadagnare ma non possiede un sito?
    Se ad una persona piace chattare e vorrebbe guadagnare?
    Se una persona volesse guadagnare attraverso un sito ma non ne dispone di uno?
    Se una persona conosce tanta gente nel web e vorrebbe fare guadagnare o guadagnare soldi?

    Queste sono alcune delle domande che ci siamo posti prima di poter aprire questo progetto.
    Bene la nostra risposta è stata: permettiamo a tutti di poter guadagnare soldi, lasciamo a loro la possibilità di decidere dove, quando e come farlo.
    Questo è il riassunto del nostro inzio del progetto. Ora passiamo alla vera e propria spiegazione di come funziona il nostro Guadagna Divertendoti :
    Gli step sono pochi,  semplici e abbiamo cercato di organizzare tutto in modo tale che il nostro servizio sia accessibile a chiunque:
    <B>
    1° Passo
    </B>

    Registrazione!
    Effettuare la registrazione è davvero semplicissimo e ti ruba meno di un minuto di orologio!
    Basta inserirei i pochi dati richiesti ricordarsi di leggere le condizioni generali e informativa sulla privacy. Poi procedere cliccando sul pulsante iscrivimi adesso.

    <B><B><B><B>2° Passo</B></B></B></B>

    Personalizza il tuo profilo (consigliato)
    Un buon profilo, completato correttamente,  è sicuaramente più  visitato ed accattivante di altri profili anonimi.
    Ora procediamo inserendo un titolo ed una descrizione personale,  stando correttamente attenti a non violare il nostro regolamento, letto ed accettato in fase di registrazione.
    Una volta efettuati i vari passaggi d’inserimento dei dati personali,  caricamento foto, informazioni di ricerca partner, e approvati dal nostro staff, sarà visualizzabile da tutti gli utenti.
    <B><B><B><B><B><B><B><B>

    3°  ed ultimo Passo</B></B></B></B></B></B></B></B>

    Ecco come si inizia a guadagnare
    Una delle metodologie usate dalle società è il “passaparola”: molte delle aziende funzionano egregiamente perchè il passaparola offre loro una grossa opportunità di stima, rispetto, qualità e gudangno del servizio, ecco perchè abbiamo deciso di prendere spunto da questo sistema.
    Noi vi forniamo materiale necessario per poter far si che il vostro passaparola funzioni.
    Invitare amici

    Accedendo al pulsante invita amici, vi forniamo la possibilità d’  invitare automaticamente, da qualsiasi tipologia di email o social-network, i vostri amici con semplici passi, come da immagine
    Basta selezionare la tipologia del servizio da cui si desidera invitare,  inserire i propri dati personali e attendere il caricamento.  Poi potrete selezionare dalla vostra lista gli amici che desiderate invitare; una volta selezionati, cliccare sul pulsante invita amici e guadagna ed automaticamente sarà processata una email con il vostro codice affiliato che spiegheremo nel passaggio successivo.
    Codice affiliato

    Il codice affiliato è  la parte più interessante del nostro portale:  per ogni utente che si registra, viene assegnato automaticamente un codice identificativo, cliccando sul pulsante “I miei guadagni” vi troverete d’avanti al vostro panello utente visualizzerete una pagina simile a questa dove troviamo in alto 6 voci:

    Totale Contabile “Il totale contabile comprende il guadagno complessivo totale da quando si è effettuata l’ iscrizione”
    Totale Disponibile “Il totale Disponibile è il guadagno complessivo accumulato da riscuotere”
    Totale Iscritti “Il totale iscritti è il numero totale di utenti portati da voi e iscritti attraverso il vostro codice affiliato “
    Totale Referenti “Il totale referenti è il numero di utenti iscritti dai vostri “sottaffiliati”
    Totale Premium “Il totale premium comprende gli utenti totali che hanno sottoscritto la premium e che si sono iscritti attraverso il vostro id utente”
    Identificativo Utente “E’ l’ indirizzo che dovete dare a tutti i vostri amici ed inserire ovunque voi vogliate “

    La richiesta di euro è possibile effettuarla in un qualsiasi momento purchè abbiate raggiunto la soglia minima di 40 € Disponibile. Per poter ricevere il pagamento è necessario che vengano compilati i dati personali che trovate cliccando sul pulsante “Modifica Dati”
    Entro e non oltre 24 ore dalla richiesta sarà effettuato il pagamento sul vostro postpay, paypal o conto bancario.
    Potrete visualizzare le statistiche cliccando sul pulsante statistiche.  Inoltre forniamo a tutti voi materiale pubblicitario,  quali banner di diverse dimensioni, con un codice identificativo da inserire nelle vostre pagine web o space.

    <a > CupidoCash </a>

    Chiedo scusa ai Moderatori se ho sbagliato sezione.

  • matt
    03/07 10:28 AM

    Thanks for the invite, papmerstato, but I think you probably smell bad.

  • revolu
    03/08 08:50 AM

    And here we go again…

  • No Thank you
    03/08 09:40 AM

    Someone asked:  “Which of the new school board majority have any education experience, in the classroom or otherwise?”

    The bios of most of the Board members can be found here.  http://www.wcpss.net/Board/boeinfo.html

    Mrs. Prickett is presently an Education Consultant with the NC Department of Public Instruction. As a WCPSS employee for over 20 years, she served as a Counselor Mentor and Lead Counselor at Leesville MS, counselor at Southeast Raleigh HS, and Apex ES. In addition, she was a Department Chairperson and Team Leader while teaching English, Language Arts, and Social Studies. She has a Master of Arts Degree from North Carolina Central University and a Bachelor of Arts Degree from North Carolina State University. Mrs. Prickett, a Raleigh native, is married with a son who attends school in WCPSS.

  • richardfoc
    03/10 08:47 AM

    I see your Mrs. Pricket and raise you one Chairman Mr. Margiotta:

    A longtime businessman, Ron Margiotta retired in 2000 with 40 years of experience in business. Mr. Margiotta is the founding owner and operator of Reliable Service Company, a warehouse and installation service business. Originally from New Jersey, Mr. Margiotta studied labor relations at St. Peter’s College. He has served on the executive committee of the Wake County Taxpayer’s Association. Prior to moving to Wake County, Mr. Margiotta was elected to a school board in the Northeast where he also served as board president for six years.

    Six years on a school board in NJ where the school districts are the size of a postage stamp. Boy, I sure am glad he is running this circus.

  • John
    03/11 11:23 AM

    It’s not just about the actul learning of material, it’s also about the children learning people skills.  This is something that has to be carefully considered when seeking the future of learning.  While the web based lives of children today have expanded their horizons globally via social networking sites, etc., their face to face social skills need to be strengthened because they are losing play time and face to face interactions with others.

    Regarding the “ramming down the throat” ideas in the original post, both sides should be taken to task on that issue, not just the liberals.  The conservatives that are ramming this change in Wake County should also be taken to task for doing exactly the same thing that they cry foul about nationally with health care.

Your Comment

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.